A Place to Read and Get Read

Why The Mets’ Lucas Duda’s Days In The Outfield Should Be Numbered

In Sports on May 29, 2013 at 6:58 pm

By: Brian Mangan

Foreword:  This article was written yesterday, a few hours prior to Lucas Duda’s super-clutch, game-winning hit off Mariano Rivera in the Subway Series.  I’m a Mets fan.  Nothing comes as a surprise.  This is Part I of a two part series.

With all the media attention focused on the epic struggles of Ike Davis, other Mets have been fortunate to have their own underwhelming performances fly under the radar.  One such Met who has struggled to a degree is Lucas Duda.

Although his surface stats appear palatable, a look under the hood reveals that Duda has failed to seize the opportunity that has been given to him to prove that he is an everyday player on a National League team.

So far this season (Ed: at the writing of this article, May 28th), Duda has a .235 batting average, a .352 on-base percentage, and a .471 slugging percentage, which is good for an OPS of 822 [FN1].  This is a marked improvement on last year’s slash line, but as I will explain, the surface offensive numbers fail to tell the full story of a defensively-challenged slugger whose performance thus far has not helped the team.

[FN1] The batting average, on-base percentage, and slugging percentage of a player are commonly abbreviated by use of a slash line (for example: .235/.352/.471) and by reference to OPS, which is on-base plus slugging percentage. 

Lucas Duda (credit: wikicommons)


The most frustrating part of Duda’s struggles is that they have taken place despite the fact that he has been given every opportunity to succeed.  Through words and actions, Duda has been told by the Mets and by Terry Collins that he is their “guy,” starting every day without fear of a platoon or benching.

In contrast, every single other Mets outfielder has been either: forced to the bench for long periods of time, stuck in a platoon, or outright sent to the minor leagues.  As the Mets fall hopelessly out of the playoff race, I believe it is time to look at Duda for what he is – a platoon outfielder – and give opportunities to some of the other players on the roster.


As mentioned above, Duda’s overall line shows a fairly robust .352 on-base percentage and .471 slugging percentage.  To his credit, he has slammed 9 home runs and collected 26 walks.  However, Duda is a well-known defensive liability and has managed only a .235 average, which is actually worse than his .252 lifetime average. Furthermore, despite batting in run-producing spots all year, and starting almost every game, Duda has managed only 16 RBI on the entire season – a number good for only fifth on the team (behind Buck, Wright, Murphy, and Byrd).

This is because Duda has done almost all of his damage this season – batting .258/.337/.602, for a 939 OPS – with the bases empty.  With runners on base (any base, any outs), his batting line drops to an incredibly low .200/.372/.267 in 78 plate appearances.  His line with runners in scoring position, an even smaller sample of 44 plate appearances, is .125/.341/.125, good for an OPS of 466.  He does not have a single extra-base hit all season with RISP.  Let that sink in for a moment.

Small sample sizes can be misleading, and I am not typically a fan of calling a player “unclutch” based on splits.  Furthermore, Duda has not historically had terrible splits with runners on.  However these numbers back up what Mets fans have seen since the start of spring training this year – a player who consistently comes up small when pitched tough.

Eight of his nine home runs have some with the bases empty (Ed. as of June 3rd, that is now nine of ten).  Pitchers seem to be wising up to this as well.  After drawing 20 walks in 24 games in April, Duda has walked only 6 times in May.  Pitchers have adjusted to Duda’s good batting eye and his passivity and, seeing that he lacks the ability to truly fight off good pitching, have attacked him more aggressively.  Whether it is physical, psychological, or the result of the inevitable adjustment of major league pitching, Duda has not been a reliable producer at the plate since his great 2011 season, when he batted .292/.370/.482 in 347 at-bats.

[FN2] Fangraphs, keeps track of a stat known as Win Probability Added (“WPA”).  If you don’t like statistics, you can skip this.  WPA measures a player’s contributions to his team’s chances of winning each game based on what they do in actual, real life, plate appearances.  WPA knows that a single to pad a nine run lead in the fifth inning contributes little to your team’s already enormous chances of winning, while a game-tying home run in the ninth is hugely important.

WPA shows that Duda earned 2.31 WPA in his great 2011, but only 0.46 in 2012.  His 0.46 WPA would have placed him #86th among all MLB hitters if he had qualified for the batting title. 

This year?  Duda’s WPA is negative – yes, negative — 0.30, which means that, when you add up all of his positive and negative contributions he had made to the Mets’ chances of winning games this  year, that he has hurt more than he has helped.  This number ranks him #123rd in MLB.  His “clutch” rating on Fangraphs confirms this writer’s observations as well, as Duda has posted a -1.01 “clutch” rating for his career.

The worst indictment of Duda comes when you realize that all of the above analysis comes at the expense of what is supposed to be Duda’s strong point, his offense.  His defense is awful, as is evidenced both by the advanced stats and the naked eye.  For instance, his awful misplay in left field in game one against the Yankees was not only ugly, but could have ended up costing the Mets’ the game.

On Fangraphs, the “fans scouting report” of Duda’s defense (a rating solicited from the fans of every player in MLB) rates him as a -10, a remarkably low number.  The advanced metrics back it up, measuring Duda as markedly below average.  In fact, they rate him as one of the worst in the game.  Duda’s ultimate zone rating (UZR) for this year is a putrid -7.3.  Defensive stats can be unreliable over small samples, but Duda’s poor rating this year is consistent with his performance in years past.  In 846 innings in 2012 he had a -35.6 UZR/150.  In 2011 it was -40.1 in 364 innings.

You don’t have to trust UZR, but I do – and to support its use, these are some of the names you’ll find in the top fifteen by that ranking: Gerardo Parra, Carlos Gomez, BJ Upton, Denard Span, Jacoby Ellsbury, Brett Gardner, Lorenzo Cain.  Some surprises appear as well (Vernon Wells, Cody Ross) but overall the list coincides with what we know about defense.  On the other end, we find Duda, who is 8th from the bottom among all major league outfielders.  He is in the same neighborhood as old, limpy Carlos Beltran, and known hacker Michael Morse.


So what do the Mets have in Duda, both today and in the future?  Why has Duda been given carte blanche to play every day when other players are a single bad performance away from being glued to the bench by Collins?

Duda has now had 1,080 major league plate appearances, in which he has hit .252/.340/.435 with only 38 home runs.  He is 27 years old.  He appears to have proven, by now, exactly what he is, namely, a pretty good platoon outfielder.  Duda holds a career .260 average and 824 OPS against righties and a .233 average and 650 OPS against lefties.

I believe that the Mets, already hopelessly out of the race, would be best served by taking away Duda’s status as a sacred cow and distributing the at-bats among players who may still have a chance, however slim, of elevating their stock.

Jordany Valdespin has languished on the bench, relegated to a bizarre pinch-hitting role where the Mets send him to the plate expecting him to hit home run every time.  Juan Lagares was brought up to the Majors, given a one week audition, then abandoned (two starts since May 14th).  Justin Turner (72 at bats all season) and Mike Baxter (77 at bats) are lucky to start twice a week.  Andrew Brown, owner of a 1097 OPS in Triple-A, got 15 at-bats before being sent back down.

Even Read Zone favorite Collin Cowgill was demoted to the minors after what was, essentially, a bad week.  Cowgill was the Opening Day center fielder, started only 6 of the 9 games after Opening Day and was given a grand total of 30 at-bats before he was marginalized.  Cowgill got 15 more at bats from April 15 through May 1 and was then demoted.  (Cowgill presently owns a 758 OPS in Triple-A, so he may not be the answer, but that is beside the point).  What kind of management is this?  And for what it’s worth Cowgill had eight RBI in those 52 plate appearances – or half of what Duda has accumulated in three times as many trips to the plate.

Ultimately, if Duda is what he has appeared to be this season – a player whose actual contribution won’t match his statistics, and who cannot adjust to being pitched tough by good pitchers – the Mets are not well-served by giving him opportunities to play at the expense of other players.

This is not to say that I don’t think there is any chance that Duda could turn things back around and hit enough to justify his fielding.  He is young enough where he still might.  I just think it’s time to see what the other kids can do out there, where we have replacement options.

Duda’s days in the outfield should be numbered.  In Part II, I will discuss what, exactly, this armchair GM thinks the team should do.

*                          *                          *

Brian Mangan is an attorney living in New York City and is often wrong.  He has nothing against Lucas Duda, honestly.  Especially because Duda kind of looks like Charlie Kelly from It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia in his ESPN profile picture.  

You can follow Brian on twitter at @brianpmangan, and The Read Zone co-founder Mike Abitabilo at @mabitab.


Postscript: Thank you to Metsblog for the link.  My timing has proven impeccable as Duda homered again last night (another solo shot).  His season OPS stands at 814, with 20 RBI.


If you are interested in writing for the Read Zone, leave a comment with your information and read this: GET READ

  1. […] Link: Why Lucas Duda’s Days In The Outfield Should Be Numbered Brian Mangan, Read Zone […]

  2. Thank you for not suggesting they try and shoehorn him into first base.

    • James — as much as I wish I could just take the compliment, that was going to be the suggestion in Part II of the series. I don’t think he’s a first baseman either — he’s a DH — but I’d much rather see the younger, faster legs out there in the outfield.

  3. So in two words, HE STINKS!!!

  4. I completely disagree he has been given “carte blanche” he and Wright are the only Mets with OPS’s above 800. He was sent down last year, has rode the pine at times, been platooned, moved around the field, moved off his true position because of a player who should have “carte blance” tattooed on his butt; Ike Davis. Duda is not a clean up hitter, he should be batting 2nd; people worry too much about speed (especially on a team that has none, who cares about different shades of slow) especially when 3 and 4 hitters are supposed to be your extra base guys, Duda gets on base.
    Duda for once in his career, has been given a solid year without having to look over his shoulder, has been the third most productive hitter, and he still gets scrutinized like this? He has manhandled the INT league that Valdespin couldn’t even handle. You got Rice pitching yesterday giving up bombs, and when the ball is scoarched over Duda’s head, Cohen says he misplayed the ball, people criticize his defense with no regard to the fact that he plays out of position for a guy with inferior offensive career numbers. I don’t really get why people are always so hard on this kid, but if Davis were held to the same standards he would have been gone a long time ago.

    • Hey Graham, thanks for the comment. Let me get #1 out of the way here, because you and I agree — this is not to criticize Duda and give Davis a pass. This is an analysis of Duda on his own merits.

      Davis has been awful, and Duda would be better as a first baseman. The point I was trying to make is that Duda is out of place in the outfield and shouldn’t be there every day. His defense is truly atrocious.

      Stay tuned for Part II!

      • Not so fast…If you are analyzing a player in regards to how they fit within the framework of a given team, and also makes points about how management handles them with respect to others, you can’t claim to be judging Duda on “his own merits”. No usefull player analysis exists within a vacuum; besides could there be a more depressing or pointless excerices with this team? He makes this team better than any alternative, especially at first base; he has better mechanics than Davis, every bit as much power, hits lefties better, and is more (gulp) consistant. I only we wish we had a team where Duda was a problem and not one of the few bright spots.

    • Great reply….and Graham fails to realize there are no other alternatives to the OF…none.

  5. I am glad I am not the only one that realized that Duda hurts us more than he helps us.I agree with everything you said. I would much rather trade Duda’s solo shots for a more athletic LF that can help us on D, on the bases and put more balls on play.
    I like Duda. I think he is a bad fit for this team.

  6. Duda is the worst outfielder in the MLB. As Mets fans, we should be somewhat insulted that the organization continues to put him out in LF.

    That being said, I don’t hate his bat, although I do think he tightens his strikezone with runners on, leading to the poor “clutch” numbers. I think Duda has a much better eye and a more consistent swing than Davis, which makes him a good candidate at 1B. Davis is a painfully overrated defensive player, and a poor hitter. You could hide Duda’s defensive deficiencies at 1B, while eliminating Davis’ negative offensive and defensive numbers by relegating him to the bench.

    I would put Valdespin in LF for a stretch and bring Puello up in RF. See what we got in these guys longterm.

    • Hahah well I wouldn’t go that far, Joe. He looks bad out there, but I’d find it hard to believe if he was the worst. The stats indicate he’s in the bottom ten though, so he may be.

      I think most of the people commenting are on the same page (or close to it) … Duda just hasn’t hit enough to stick in the outfield.

  7. Reblogged this on Scott A. Sherman and commented:
    Very good article on Lucas Duda

  8. […] options at first base.  First and foremost among these is Lucas Duda, who has been much maligned, even on this very site.  Back in May, the Read Zone was ahead of the curve when we stated that “Duda’s days […]

  9. […] May 29, 2013: Why The Mets’ Lucas Duda’s Days In The Outfield Should Be Numbered […]

  10. […] Cowgill homered on Opening Day 2013, but was never given an opportunity to play after that.  As we wrote in May last year: […]

  11. After going over a few off the blog articles on your web site, I seriously like your technique of blogging.
    I saved it to my bookmark siute list and will be checking
    back soon. Take a look at my web site too and tell me how you feel.

  12. s SURPLUS, the Tea Party Movement disappeared from USA politics for over 20 years until 1980 when Ronald Regan became President.
    I like the to call him the GSP of system advertising, the Georges St-Pierre of e-systems administration’.
    In evaluating net branches, I thought it best to
    let you Sink or Swimmers in on a little secret.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,779 other followers

%d bloggers like this: